By William Mayfield
For the third week in a row, the University of Tennessee Men’s basketball team sits atop the AP Poll as the number one college basketball team in America. This may come as a shock to many, as it is only Tennessee’s fourth week in program history as number one. While none of the players on this team were even alive 25 years ago, many of the fans that fill Thompson Boling Arena were. As often happens when a team experiences success seemingly out of nowhere, there has been much speculation that many Vol hoops fans are simply “on the bandwagon.” Tennessee certainly isn’t a blue blood basketball school, but they are no stranger to success on the hardwood. As most Vol fans know, there have been periods of success and periods of suffering over the last 25 years for Tennessee basketball. While it has not always been smooth, it sure has been an interesting journey to the top for the Vols.
The Kevin O’Neill Era
Prior to the ’94-’95 season, Tennessee hired Kevin O’Neill to be its 15th basketball coach. There was optimism on the hill after a disappointing 65-90 five-year run from Wade Houston, father of Tennessee legend Allan Houston. O’Neill was coming off back to back 20-win seasons at Marquette and a sweet 16 appearance in the ’93-’94 season. It seemed like a great hire for a once proud Tennessee program.
While Tennessee has often played second fiddle to its neighbors to the north in blue, there was once a time where Tennessee was the center of the college basketball universe. Those were the days of Coach Ray Mears and the “Ernie and Bernie Show.”
Current Vols Admiral Schofield and Grant Williams (pictured on the right) pay homage to Ernie Grunfeld and Bernard King’s Sports Illustrated cover (pictured on the left).
Ernie Grunfeld and Bernard King left their mark on Rocky Top. In addition to appearing on a Sports Illustrated cover, ESPN made a “30 for 30” documentary in 2013 on the two friends’ time at Tennessee. Despite their lasting impact and their teams’ 43-12 record from 1975-1977, Tennessee never made it out of the first round of the NCAA Tournament while these two dawned the orange and white.
Tennessee has worn these “throwback” uniforms a handful of times this year as a nod to the program’s history.
Unfortunately, the Kevin O’Neill experiment never panned out for Tennessee. O’Neill has had problems everywhere he’s been both on and off the floor. His time at Tennessee was marred by his poor relationships with some of his best players, Aaron Green in particular. O’Neill often poked fun at Green for being from the country (Cleveland, TN). He nicknamed him “Hee-Haw” and “Henry the Hick.”
“He’d always poke fun at me for being from the country,” said Green in an interview about O’Neill. “The funny thing is, he was from the country too. But I didn’t feel very comfortable ragging him about it.”
Green went on to be a graduate assistant for Bruce Pearl at Tennessee and is now the head coach at Oak Ridge High School, where he has a 78-14 record in his first three seasons. O’Neill was fired at Tennessee after three years and a 36-47 record.
The Jerry Green Era
In 1997 Tennessee hired Jerry Green to be its 16th basketball coach. Green came from Oregon and was coming off three straight winning seasons for the Ducks.
Despite their lack of success in previous seasons, Tennessee had talent returning and there was optimism. In addition to veteran guard Brandon Wharton, Green brought in two exciting freshmen, Tony Harris and Isaiah Victor, and returned sophomores C.J. Black and Charles Hathaway. This core, along with the addition of All-Sec forwards Vincent Yarbrough and Ron Slay, and NBA lottery pick Marcus Haislip, led to one of the most successful periods in Tennessee basketball history. After a 20-9 season in ’97-’98, the Vols won back to back regular season SEC East Championships in ’98-’99 and ’99-’00. Among the highlights from those two seasons were sweeping Kentucky in ’98-’99 and a Sweet 16 Appearance in ’99-’00.
Unfortunately, Green’s time at Tennessee was in part defined by some of the same trouble that Coach Mears faced, which was underwhelming performance in the postseason. Even the ’99-’00 Sweet 16 team was eliminated from the NCAA Tournament by an 8-seed North Carolina team. At the time, this was Tennessee’s best chance in school history to reach a Final Four, which still eludes them to this day.
It could be argued that Green was a victim of his own recruiting success. All in all, Green’s run at Tennessee was a good one as he finished with a 89-63 record. Green made the NCAA tournament and won 20+ games each season he coached at Tennessee. However, he never fully connected with the fan base, who’s attendance did not match the team’s success, and he reportedly did not get along with his superiors at Tennessee. A mid-season collapse in his final year and subsequent first round exit at the hands of UNC-Charlotte led to Green’s exit in 2001.
Marcus Haislip (left) and Vincent Yarbrough (right), who played most of their Tennessee careers under Jerry Green, were both drafted in the NBA Draft. Haislip was selected 13th overall in the 2002 draft and Yarbrough was selected 33rd in the same draft.
The Buzz Peterson Era
Buzz Peterson took over on Rocky Top in 2001 and Vol fans were hoping he could help Tennessee make the jump that Jerry Green never could. Fans were excited about the young coach who had once been Michael Jordan’s roommate at North Carolina. In fact, Peterson and Jordan remain close and Peterson currently serves as the Assistant General Manager for the Charlotte Hornets, a team Jordan owns roughly 90% of. Peterson came to Tennessee having led his teams to four straight winning seasons at Appalachian State and Tulsa.
Buzz Peterson (left) was a college roomate of Michael Jordan’s (right) at North Carolina.
Unfortunately, Buzz’s teams went in the opposite direction of Green’s. Despite losing seniors Tony Harris and Isaiah Victor, Tennessee was returning Ron Slay, Vincent Yarbrough, and Marcus Haislip for the ’01-’02 campaign. Optimism abounded, but the Vols only managed a 15-16 record and failed to even make the NIT. Peterson rebounded nicely the next year, going 17-12 after losing two players to the draft, but this was not enough to make the NCAA Tournament. Peterson’s next two seasons were marred in mediocrity and he was relieved of his duties after four seasons and a 61-59 record.
Tennessee was five years removed from true relevance, and their leading scorer over the previous two seasons, Scooter McFadgon, was graduating. The men’s basketball program was becoming a bit of an afterthought, especially given the success of the women’s program and the undying love Vol fans have for their football team. Few had any idea who would replace Buzz Peterson, and honestly, few cared. The day Bruce Pearl was announced as Tennessee’s basketball coach was arguably one of the least eventful days in his six years at Tennessee.
The Bruce Pearl Era
Unbeknownst to many Tennessee fans, Bruce Pearl was no stranger to success before coming to Tennessee. In nine seasons at Southern Indiana, Pearl won a NCAA Division II National Championship, appeared in two other Division II Final Fours, and never won less than 22 games. Following his stint at Southern Indiana, Pearl took Wisconsin-Milwaukee to two NCAA Tournaments and one Sweet 16 in four seasons as their head coach. The Sweet 16, at that time, was the furthest Tennessee had ever advanced in the NCAA Tournament, so the stage was no issue for Pearl. What Tennessee needed was life in the program, and no one was better suited for that than Pearl.
The ’05-’06 Vols quietly started 6-0, but the wins were over mid-majors and smaller schools. It was not until a 95-78 win over an absolutely loaded 6th ranked Texas team in Austin, coached by Rick Barnes coincidentally, that Tennessee basketball was officially back on the map. A young, relatively unknown former Mr. Basketball from Kentucky named Chris Lofton had 21 points in that game and a resurgent C.J. Watson added 17 to set the tone for what the year was going to be like.
Chris Lofton (right) hitting a crucial three-point shot over Texas star Kevin Durant. Lofton, a lightly recruited former Mr. Basketball in Kentucky, finished his career as one of the most decorated Vols in program history.
Tennessee was small (6’4 on average) and that fit what Bruce Pearl wanted to do. He loved to press and he let his kids shoot it. Tennessee was never out of the game with their ability to get points in bunches on the break and cause problems for opponents in the back court. The Vols could shoot the lights out, and Chris Lofton was becoming the star that Kentucky so desperately wanted, but passed on when they had their opportunity. Tennessee won the SEC East over eventual national champion Florida, who the Vols beat twice in the regular season. Pearl’s Vols finished 12-4 in the conference and finished the season 22-8 overall. Come selection Sunday, Tennessee fans were pleasantly surprised to see a “2” by their name, the highest seed in school history.
The moment turned out to be a bit too big for the Vols. They fell to Wichita State in the second round of the NCAA Tournament after narrowly escaping an upset against Winthrop in the first round. While there was some disappointment, Pearl had accomplished what he set out to do, which was to put Tennessee back on the map.
The following year, Pearl added an impressive group of recruits in Duke Crews, Wayne Chism, and Ramar Smith. Tennessee had not been able to lure talent like this in many years, and the Vols were slowly but surely resurrecting men’s basketball on campus. The Vols continued to be one of the only programs in the country to have success against Billy Donovan and Florida.
Pearl was becoming known as a master marketer for his success on the recruiting trail and his ability to put butts in the seats. He embraced the success of the women’s team and was close with Coach Summitt. He connected with Vol fans and was not afraid to do or say anything, including painting his chest at a women’s game, to promote the big orange. Further, the excitement generated by Pearl led to renovations to Thompson Boling Arena and the construction of Tennessee’s practice facility, Pratt Pavilion.
Pat Summitt (left) as a cheerleader at a Tennessee men’s basketball game and Bruce Pearl (right) with his chest painted for a Tennessee Lady Vols game
Tennessee broke ground on their state of the art practice facility in August 2006. Pratt Pavilion houses two full-size basketball courts, one for each of Tennessee’s men’s and women’s teams, as well as an athletic training room, a weight room, a film-study room and recruiting lounges.
As much as people loved Pearl, none of his marketing and charisma would have done much good had he not won on the court. The product Pearl put out there was exciting, and they won much more than they lost. In ’06-’07, the Vols upset Virginia as a 5-seed and faced a 1-seed Ohio State team in the Sweet 16. Despite taking a 20-point lead, Tennessee fell by a point as Ramar Smith’s last second shot attempt was blocked by future number one overall NBA draft pick Greg Oden. Despite the loss, Tennessee was young, and expectations were sky high for the following year.
The Vols started the ’07-’08 year 24-2 and were ranked 2nd in the nation. Chris Lofton had come into the season as a pre-season first-team All-American. The Vols were crazy deep and experienced with the likes of JaJuan Smith, Ramar Smith, J.P. Prince, Wayne Chism, Brian WIlliams….the list goes on. What stood between them and a number one ranking was an undefeated Memphis team and a coach named John Calipari.
As most Vol fans remember, the 1 vs. 2 matchup in Fedex Forum was likely the biggest game in Tennessee history. An in-state battle between two teams with disdain for each other with everything on the line was what Bruce Pearl was built for. Tennessee took down Derrick Rose and the Tigers 66-62, and for the first time in school history, Tennessee was the number one team in the country.
Former Tennessee forward Duke Crews celebrating the Vols’ 66-62 win at Memphis in 2008. This catapulted Tennessee to their fist number one ranking in school history.
The ranking was short lived as Tennessee fell to Vanderbilt at Memorial Gymnasium the following Tuesday. Despite winning the SEC regular season crown and earning a 2-seed in the NCAA Tournament, the ’07-’08 Vols truly peaked too early. An early exit in the SEC Tournament and a Sweet 16 loss to Louisville were tough to swallow.
While Pearl continued to have success at Tennessee, he was never able to replicate anything like the night he took down Memphis. The following three years, Pearl did not earn a seed higher than six in the NCAA Tournament. Despite being a Scotty Hopson made free throw away from the Final Four in ’09-’10, the identity of his early Tennessee teams were lost. Those early teams looked more like the current Vols. They were made up of overlooked high school guys who bought in and played together, despite being undersized for their position.
While Pearl was able to recruit guys like 5-stars Tobias Harris and Scotty Hopson, he strayed away from the press he was known for in his later years with Tennessee. Hopson and Harris had a lot of success for the Vols, with Hopson arguably being one of the best players for Tennessee this century. However, they did not truly fit what Pearl had done in the past.
An even bigger problem for Pearl was that Tennessee was looking very unimpressive off the court. An incident involving a few of his players led to the dismissal of key starter Tyler Smith and suspensions for other key players. In true Pearl fashion, he took a depleted roster and defeated a number one Kansas team in Thompson Boling the very next game. It had a hint of the wins over Florida in his first year at Tennessee.
But Pearl’s ultimate undoing, unfortunately, was himself.
He had always been an aggressive recruiter. When he admitted to lying to the NCAA about a barbecue involving future Ohio State point guard Aaron Craft, he was suspended for a handful of conference games. Ultimately, that Tennessee team nearly missed the tournament after a promising early start and top ten ranking. After a blowout loss to Michigan in the first round of the NCAA Tournament, Tennessee essentially had no choice but to relieve Pearl of his duties after the ’10-’11 season.
Pearl would ultimately serve a show cause penalty and resurface at Auburn a few years later. Auburn and Tennessee shared the regular season SEC Title this past season and Pearl still talks very highly of his time at Tennessee.
The Cuonzo Martin Era
After six straight years in the NCAA Tournament, it felt like Tennessee basketball was crashing and burning. Scotty Hopson and Tobias Harris had decided to turn pro and the media picked Tennessee to finish 13th in the conference before the season. Cuonzo Martin, who had a reputation as a tough, no nonsense, defensive minded coach, was there to clean up the program. He had played for Gene Keady at Purdue and wanted to instill the principles he learned there at Tennessee. Unfortunately, Martin’s entire recruiting class consisted of three 2-stars and one 3-star, so he was fighting an uphill battle.
Martin’s Vols got off to a horrific start to the season. After hard fought, close losses in the Maui Invitational, there was reason for optimism. Newcomer transfer, Jerrone Maymon, had emerged with a 32-point and 20-rebound performance in a double overtime loss to Memphis on the Island. However, after losses to Oakland, Pitt, Austin Peay, and College of Charleston, the Vols found themselves 3-6 and firmly out of NCAA Tournament contention. Things did not get much better in conference, as Tennessee started their conference slate 2-5 and found themselves at 10-12 overall.
However, Martin was able to turn things around and win 8 of the next 9 and complete a season sweep of top-10 nationally ranked Florida. The Vols entered the SEC Tournament right on the bubble, but fell in the first round to Ole Miss and ended up in the NIT.
Despite missing out on the NCAA Tournament, Vol fans were pleased. Tennessee had finished 2nd in the conference, 11 spots ahead of where the media picked them. Jordan McRae had emerged as a star, and Martin had picked up 5-star recruit Jarnell Stokes from Memphis midseason. It appeared as if Tennessee’s set back would be only temporary.
Jarnell Stokes (top left), Jordan McRae (top right), and Josh Richardson played for Cuonzo Martin while at Tennessee. All three spent time with NBA teams and McRae won a championship with the Cleveland Cavaliers in 2016.
Unfortunately, the next season saw more of the same. While Tennessee started the season a bit better, a disturbing trend emerged. In consecutive matchups, Tennessee failed to cross the 40-point threshold against Georgetown and Virginia. While neither of these games resulted in blowout losses, the brand of basketball Cuonzo Martin was selling to the fans was not nearly as exciting as the high octane, up tempo game Pearl had introduced eight years prior. After four consecutive losses to unranked teams and an 11-10 start to the season, Tennessee attempted another late season rescue. Despite notching 20 wins and an 11-7 conference record, the Vols bid fell just short on selection Sunday as they were snubbed a second year in a row.
Fortunately for Martin, he returned nearly everyone. Further, Josh Richardson was emerging as a diamond in the rough that Martin had originally recruited to go to Missouri State, where he coached previously. The sophomore’s emergence as one of the top defensive players in the conference, in addition to the progress of Maymon, Stokes, McRae, and Trae Golden, led to extremely high expectations and a pre season top 25 ranking for the first time in Coach Martin’s time at Tennessee.
Again, the Vols got off to a slow start and again they found themselves in serious trouble in regards to the postseason. They were 16-11 overall and 7-7 in conference. Tennessee fans had had enough and nearly 40,000 of them signed a petition asking athletic director Dave Hart to fire Cuonzo Martin and rehire Bruce Pearl, whose show cause penalty was due to expire the coming year allowing him to be rehired.
This time, however, Martin’s late season rescue attempt worked. Tennessee played themselves into an 11-seed and a first four matchup with Iowa, which they won. They then upset Umass and struck some good fortune when 14-seed Mercer upset 3-seed Duke. The Vols avenged their NIT loss to Mercer the previous season and found themselves in the Sweet 16. Tennessee fell just short after a controversial charge call against Jarnell Stokes led to a Michigan victory, but Tennessee had made the Sweet 16 from an 11-seed and all seemed good on the hill.
This controversial charge call was all that stood between Tennessee and their second Elite 8 appearance in program history.
While it looked as if Martin would be signing long term with Tennessee, Pearl took an opportunity at Auburn. However, Martin shocked some in the college basketball world by leaving for Cal a few weeks later. It can only be assumed that Martin did not appreciate the petition, and many in the media viewed the petition as a black eye for the Tennessee fan base. If the following three years were the gauge for that, it would be hard to argue otherwise.
The Donnie Tyndall Era
After striking out on a few big names, Tennessee hired Donnie Tyndall from Southern Miss for the ’14-’15 season. Jordan McCrae decided to declare for the draft and Trae Golden transferred, leaving the Vols with little returning. All in all, Tennessee lost a whopping ten players from the previous campaign.
Tennessee did have reason to be excited as Josh Richardson had become an NBA prospect and former 5-star Robert Hubbs appeared to be fully healthy for the first time in his Tennessee career.
In a strange turn of events, Tennessee found themselves off to an unusually hot start. 17 games in, Tennessee found themselves at 12-5, 4-1 in conference, and projected to make the NCAA Tournament. Unfortunately, SEC teams seemed to adapt to Donnie Tyndall’s unique “amoeba” zone defense the second time they saw it, and the Vols sputtered down the stretch. The Vols finished the season 16-16 and did not even make the NIT.
Tyndall’s problems were just beginning…
Recruiting violations resulted in Tyndall losing top recruits and he was eventually relieved of his duties. Tyndall is currently serving a 10-year show cause penalty.
With the air almost fully out of the program, the Vols were in search of a third coach in as many years. Much like when Coach Pearl was hired, there was only a limited amount of excitement when Rick Barnes was hired as Tennessee’s 21st head basketball coach.
The Rick Barnes Era
Most fans at Tennessee knew at the time that Rick Barnes was far more than they deserved. Two of their last three coaches had succumbed to NCAA violations, and fans had run off the other. Barnes had been at Texas for 17 years and made the NCAA Tournament in 16 of those years. As a team that had more often than not found themselves out of the dance over the last 25 years, Tennessee should be thrilled with the idea of continued relevance.
Barnes had a reputation as a fantastic recruiter. The list of names he had lured to Texas, which was traditionally more of a football school like Tennessee, read as follows:
T.J. Ford, P.J. Tucker, D.J, Augustin, Daniel Gibson, Lamarcus Aldridge, and Kevin Durant.
Tennessee fans were familiar with Durant. Chris Lofton had actually hit a miraculous shot in Durant’s face to beat Texas, helping establish Lofton as one of the best players in the country. Durant had gone on to win an NBA MVP and has since become a two-time NBA Champion.
The concerns centering around Barnes were that, on a relative scale, he probably could have done more with all that talent at Texas. Barnes’ teams only made one Final Four in his time at Texas. Other concerns were that at the age of 60, how would recruiting go now and how quickly could he turn things around?
Little in his first two years led to optimism. Barnes did not sign one top-100 recruit and had failed to finish above .500 in either of his first two years. Prior to the 2017-2018 season, the SEC Media again rated Tennessee 13th in the pre-season. Grant Williams and Admiral Schofield had other plans.
The vols got an early season win in the Atlantis Tournament against 18th ranked Purdue. Tennessee then let a half time lead slip to eventual National Champion Villanova, but showed that they belonged. The Vols entered SEC play 11-2 and ranked. After starting conference play 0-2, Barnes got a much needed win over rival Kentucky and reeled off nine wins in their next 10 games. After pulling off their first sweep of Kentucky since the Jerry Green Days, Tennessee entered the final game of the regular season with a chance to win the Conference.
After defeating Georgia, the Vols celebrated a share of the SEC regular season championship. New athletic director, Phillip Fulmer, spoke to a sold out crowd along side Rick Barnes. Grant Williams was named SEC player of the year as a sophomore. Despite narrowly losing in the Conference title game to Kentucky and an earlier than expected exit to Cinderella Story Loyola-Chicago in the NCAA Tournament, Tennessee basketball was officially back.
Vol forward Admiral Schofield cutting down the nets at Thompson Boling Arena after clinching a share of the ’17-’18 SEC Regular Season Championship
This Season
Tennessee came into this season with high expectations. James Daniel III was the only departure that received relevant minutes from the year prior. Tennessee has responded fantastically.
At 21-1, their only loss is an overtime loss to Kansas in November. Grant Williams fouled out with over five minutes remaining in that game. Tennessee has boasted a win over then number one Gonzaga on a neutral floor and has a school record 17-game winning streak. Grant Williams and Admiral Schofield find themselves on the final 20 list for the Wooden Award, and Tennessee is the only remaining SEC team without a conference loss. In their most recent win, Williams, Schofield, Jordan Bowden, Lamonte Turner, and Jordan Bone all scored in double digits. Many around the country believe Bone is emerging as one of the top point guards in the nation.
Where From Here?
While Tennessee is experiencing heights they never have before, they have been near the top of the college basketball world a few times in the past. What has eluded them is a Final Four and perennial success. With their facilities and support, Tennessee has potential to become a college basketball blue blood. With FBI scandals and agent misconduct rampant in college basketball, Rick Barnes has kept his program headline-free in that regard. Even the recruiting is picking up as 5-star point guard Josiah James is set to suit up in the orange and white next year.
The ride is setting up to be an absolute must see.
Tennessee has two matchups left with a much improved top-5 Kentucky team. There’s a chance they’ll eventually have to fight their way through arguably the best crew of freshmen at Duke since the Fab 5 at Michigan. The road will not be easy.
But if anyone can handle it, it’s this group.
This is the group that had the highest fall grade point average of any Tennessee basketball team in the last 12 years…
This is the group that would rather play the Catan board game than play on their phones…
This is the group that sees fans with flat tires and takes time out of their day to help…
This is the group that has an old fashioned coach who doesn’t tell them they’re perfect and they ask for him to keep doing it…
This is the group that goes to the Lady Vols’ games and shoots promo videos for the football team…
This is the group that has a coach who will go to your baptism 90 minutes before tipoff…
This is the group that wasn’t on the first page of Rivals…or the second…or the third…or maybe even the fourth…
This is the group…at least for now…with a number 1 next to their name on the left…
Maybe, just maybe, this could be the group that cuts down the nets in Minneapolis.